What To Know
- The Dell M6800 can be configured with up to an Intel Xeon E3-1505M v5 processor, while the HP ZBook 17 goes even further with the option for an Intel Xeon E3-1575M v5.
- The Dell M6800 offers a maximum of 8GB of dedicated VRAM, while the HP ZBook 17 can be equipped with up to 16GB of VRAM.
- This longer battery life of the ZBook 17 makes it a better choice for users who need to work on the go for extended periods.
Choosing the right workstation can be a daunting task, especially when considering heavy-duty applications like 3D rendering, video editing, and engineering simulations. Two top contenders in this arena are the Dell Precision M6800 and the HP ZBook 17. Both boast impressive specs and features, but which one emerges as the victor? This detailed comparison dives deep into the key aspects of each workstation to help you make an informed decision.
Performance: Powering Through Demanding Workloads
The Dell M6800 and HP ZBook 17 pack a punch when it comes to performance. Both offer a range of Intel Xeon and Core i7 processors, along with high-end NVIDIA Quadro graphics cards. The Dell M6800 can be configured with up to an Intel Xeon E3-1505M v5 processor, while the HP ZBook 17 goes even further with the option for an Intel Xeon E3-1575M v5. This translates to significant processing power for tackling complex tasks.
In terms of graphics, both workstations offer a selection of NVIDIA Quadro cards, ranging from the entry-level Quadro M1000M to the powerful Quadro M5000M. The Dell M6800 offers a maximum of 8GB of dedicated VRAM, while the HP ZBook 17 can be equipped with up to 16GB of VRAM. This extra VRAM in the ZBook 17 can be crucial for rendering high-resolution images and videos.
Display: Visual Clarity for Professional Work
Both workstations feature 17.3-inch displays, but the ZBook 17 pulls ahead with its optional 4K UHD (3840 x 2160) resolution. This provides a level of detail and clarity that is unmatched by the M6800’s 1080p Full HD display. However, the M6800 offers a wider viewing angle, which can be beneficial for collaborative work.
Design and Build: Durability and Portability
The Dell M6800 and HP ZBook 17 are both built for durability and portability. The M6800 boasts a sleek and compact design, while the ZBook 17 features a more rugged and professional aesthetic. Both workstations are MIL-STD-810G certified, ensuring their ability to withstand harsh conditions.
In terms of weight, the M6800 is slightly lighter, making it more convenient for frequent travel. However, the ZBook 17’s larger footprint and sturdier build provide a sense of stability and security.
Connectivity and Features: Staying Connected and Productive
Both workstations offer a wide range of connectivity options, including multiple USB ports, Thunderbolt 3, HDMI, and DisplayPort. The ZBook 17 also includes a built-in SD card reader, which can be useful for photographers and other professionals who work with media files.
The M6800 features a fingerprint reader for added security, while the ZBook 17 offers an optional smart card reader for enhanced authentication. Both workstations come with a range of software applications pre-installed, including Adobe Creative Cloud and Autodesk software.
Battery Life: Powering Through the Day
Battery life is a crucial consideration for mobile professionals. The Dell M6800 offers a battery life of up to 8 hours, while the HP ZBook 17 can last up to 10 hours. This longer battery life of the ZBook 17 makes it a better choice for users who need to work on the go for extended periods.
Price: Finding the Right Value
Price is a significant factor in the decision-making process. The Dell M6800 is generally more affordable than the HP ZBook 17, especially when considering the higher-end configurations. However, the ZBook 17’s superior performance and features often justify its higher price tag.
The Verdict: Choosing the Best Workstation for Your Needs
Ultimately, the choice between the Dell M6800 and HP ZBook 17 depends on your specific needs and priorities. If you prioritize portability and affordability, the Dell M6800 is a solid choice. However, if you require the ultimate performance, a stunning 4K display, and longer battery life, the HP ZBook 17 is the clear winner.
Beyond the Comparison: Finding the Perfect Fit
While this comparison highlights the key differences between the Dell M6800 and HP ZBook 17, there are other important factors to consider. These include:
- Software compatibility: Ensure that your chosen workstation supports the specific software applications you need for your work.
- Warranty and support: Look for a workstation with a comprehensive warranty and reliable customer support.
- Upgradeability: Consider the workstation’s upgrade options for future needs.
Quick Answers to Your FAQs
Q: Which workstation is better for 3D rendering?
A: The HP ZBook 17 generally offers better performance for 3D rendering due to its optional 16GB of VRAM and powerful processor options.
Q: Which workstation is more portable?
A: The Dell M6800 is slightly lighter and more compact, making it more portable than the ZBook 17.
Q: Which workstation has a better display?
A: The HP ZBook 17 offers a higher-resolution 4K UHD display, providing superior visual clarity.
Q: Which workstation is more affordable?
A: The Dell M6800 is generally more affordable than the HP ZBook 17.
Q: Which workstation has better battery life?
A: The HP ZBook 17 offers a longer battery life of up to 10 hours compared to the M6800’s 8 hours.
By carefully considering your specific needs and weighing the pros and cons of each workstation, you can confidently choose the Dell M6800 or HP ZBook 17 that best fits your professional workflow.
